Thanks everyone for the lip suggestions
Last night I went home and tried out all the suggestions I could do there. First I tried
animeangel’s suggestion of foundation and lip balm. The color was good, but the texture didn’t work for me. I have really dry skin, so my lips are very dry and flaky. The foundation swam around in there and got gummy. Le sigh. I have mutant lips. So I tried the concealer, because I don’t use an oil-free concealer so I thought that might work better, but i had the same problem. It didn’t work for me, but I must stress that the color was really good, so if you don’t have peely lips it is definitely worth a try.
So at lunch I went to MAC to try out
klytaemnestra’s suggestion of MAC’s “Myth” color. Google pictures of it looked promising. I went to MAC and a guy named Jacob helped me out. I tried it with and without lipgloss and liner. It looks great. I’m interested to try it with a lip brush (I like those). The coverage is good and the texture is nice and creamy so I don’t get flake problems. So I bought the lipstick in Myth and a tube of Plushglass in Wildly Lush, which looks amazing on top of it. It’s a good look that may work for noncosplay stuff with a slightly heavier eye. (I’m thinking Twiggy.)
Of course, I just now realized I forgot to check out the MAC Shadesticks, which I had been interested in. Panacea81 uses them in a lot of her Youtube videos, so I thought I’d check them out. But I forgot, oh no. But the lipstick is great.
